
I’ve said it before, but Chinese Tex-Mex is pretty legit. Not legit in that it is authentic in any way, shape or form. But legit in the fact that its usually pretty awesome when you’re hungover and want someone to deliver you tacos while you lay on the couch all day watching West Wing. The First Tortilla Grill was not legit. It wasn’t horrible, and maybe I’ll have to try it again when I’ve got the Tequila flu, but overall I was not impressed.
To put it plainly, there wasn’t much to get excited about. The ingredients weren’t super fresh. the meat wasn’t expertly prepared (save the shrimp) and despite trying to fake authenticity by calling steak tacos ‘tacos el carbon’, there was nothing authentic about these tacos. It was basically like going to a below average Chinese restaurant and feeling like you’re rolling the dice with each bite whether you’re going to get food poisoning or not.
Oddly enough there was one taco that they did really well…the shrimp taco. I will get into that more below, but if you happen to go there I recommend a shrimp hard taco. If you don’t partake in the consumption of crustaceans, I would still offer this simple tip; hard tacos over soft taco from here.
Shrimp Hard Taco – The one shining star of this taco outing was the shrimp hard tacos. They were grilled nicely, and I’m a fan of whatever they grilled the shrimp in (if I had to venture a guess I’d say salt, pepper, cayenne pepper and a touch of garlic powder). The taco shell was open and wider like I mentioned in the Ay! Carumba! review last week, and I’m sold on this tortilla shaping. The cheese was typical shredded cheddar, the pico was average and the lettuce was…well shredded iceberg. But those shrimp were great, and because of that I give this 3.5 out of 5 tortillas.
Chili Soft Taco - The best description I could give this taco would be ‘hot mess’. It was so sloppy I couldn’t even open the tortilla to take a picture of its content. Grease had seeped into the tortilla and sort of glued it shut. I can’t speak definitely, but I’m pretty sure this isn’t a good thing. The chili had a weird aftertaste too. It was reminiscent of the aftertaste of homemade chili, but a little too bitter. I got the impression if I got there at like 9 am when they made this chili it would have been decent, but after probably sitting under a heat lamp for 12 hours…ew. I give this 2 out of 5 tortillas.
Steak Soft Taco / Black Bean Soft Taco – There was nothing in the former taco but gristly steak. It was not “al carbon” as advertised. It was just mehh skirt steak done on a slinger (diner grill). As for the Black Bean taco, it was arguably the most nondescript taco I’ve ever had. The only thing I can say is that the soft taco again was molded closed, this time by black bean paste. It was not horrible, but not good either. In short it was the very definition of taco purgatory. I give both these tacos 2 out of 5 tortillas.
Chicken Hard Taco – I had high hopes for this taco based on the shrimp taco, but it fell short. The chicken was kinda gristly. The cheese, lettuce, pico and sour cream were just there. Overall another relatively non-descript taco. I give this taco a 2 out of 5 tortillas.
Bottom line: If you go here for tacos, get the shrimp hard taco or prepared to be disappointed. I should add however that the quesadillas looked pretty stellar (even if they spelt it Quecidilla on the wall advertisement).
Website: www.456taco.com
Twitter: No Tweets, Just Meat
Facebook: No pokes allowed.
The First Tortilla Grill (Rockville Centre, Long Island)
169 Maple Ave.
Rockville Centre, NY 11570
Peace,
- TS










